Must There Be a Superman

In Batman v Superman (2016) there is a blink and you will miss it moment referencing the Superman #247 (January 1972), story “Must There Be a Superman” by Elliot Maggin. The extensive credits of the film make no mention of Maggin. On hearing of this Maggin tweeted I’m pissed. In July that year the San Diego Comic Con presented Maggin with the Bill Finger Award for Excellence in Comic Book Writing, an award named after an often unacknowledged writer of Batman comics. Accepting the award Maggin vowed to take on the insidious work-for-hire employment status of many comic book professionals. In my forthcoming book Superman: The Persistence of an American Icon I detail the stormy relationship between Siegel and Shuster and DC and also point to the work of many other “work-for-hire” creators, like Maggin, who shaped theĀ  Superman we know today.